Erotica Gravy Train

My brother-in-law says he wants to write an erotic book.

What he really means is: I want to get rich.

Everyone is talking about erotica lately. The words “mommy-porn” are on everyone’s lips, from Dr. Phil to Dr. Oz to the ladies of The View. E.L. James’ “Shades” series has pushed erotica and erotic romance into the mainstream spotlight. Suddenly my “smut writing” isn’t such a shameful secret the family doesn’t want to talk about–oh no, not anymore–now it’s a lucrative career choice!

Everyone wants to ride that erotica gravy train, bay-bee!

My brother-in-law took a look at my current success in the genre and decided that he, too, could write about inserting tab A into slot B and make a million dollars.

And he’s not the only one.

I get a lot of letters asking me what amounts to: “How do I get rich writing erotica?”

It’s a hard question to answer, because I didn’t set out to make a million dollars writing about sex. I didn’t even set out to make a million dollars as a writer. All I wanted to do was find a larger audience for my year’s worth of work at Literotica.

Maybe I’m a cynic, but I have a kind of “if you build it, they will come” philosophy when it comes to this business. There is no magic wand, no secret formula for success. You have to be passionate about and love what you do, whatever it is, whether that’s being a writer or being a chef or working in advertising. No one ever gets rich inserting Tab A into Slot B–or writing about it, for that matter.

If it were that simple, we’d all be doing it, right?

Writing about sex may sound simple, but it isn’t. Writing itself probably looks easy-peasy from the outside. You sit at a laptop and peck away on the keyboard until you have enough words on the screen. Taa daa, you’re a writer! Ask the thousands of people who fail to finish Nanowrimo every year how easy it is to write a novel, to commit to writing every single day, or even just five days a week.

I happen to love writing. I also love sex. And I have a very vivid imagination. That has served to give me a modicum of success in the erotica and erotic romance genre. I’m no E.L. James, but I’m making a very good living writing about similar topics (although I tend to push things to far edgier places!) and the market for it seems to be widening.

So if you are a writer who is looking to get on the erotica gravy-train and want to know if you can make a living doing it, my answer would be a hesitant and conditional “yes”–if you’re looking for short-term gain and not long-term stability.

Right now, erotica sells, and it sells well. There are many well-known authors out there who have opted to write erotica under a pen name who are doing quite well pumping out several 2-3K shorts a week, selling them for $2.99, and in a very minimal amount of time, making enough money to quit their day jobs.

But the question is, what is erotica’s future? We have to remember that self-publishing is in its infancy, and while erotica and erotic romance have absolutely and unquestionably driven the sales of Kindles and Nooks everywhere, there is no telling how stable this genre is going to be in the future. We only have to look at how often this genre has been attacked, from Amazon pulling books from their shelves, Apple removing the genre from their bestseller lists, to Paypal refusing to pay for it, to see that job-stability is an issue for erotica writers.

My feeling is that this “gold-rush” – both in self-publishing and in erotica writing – is going to end, at least as we know it. Like those who never finished Nanowrimo, there will be writers who wanted to jump on the erotica gravy train who put out a few stories, made a few sales, and gave it up because they didn’t make a million in their first few months. Or, like my brother-in-law, they’ll talk a lot about wanting to write it so they can get rich too…but they never will.

And yes, there will be writers who make money at it, who take advantage of the “gold-rush” and pay off their student loans, their credit card debt, maybe even their mortgages. And good for them!

But in the end, the glut of work being rushed onto Amazon’s virtual shelves on a daily basis will end up settling to the bottom. Big publishing has known for a long time that the bell-curve doesn’t apply to books–which is why they invest all their money into those books at the top they think will sell best. They know that most books, whether they’re self-or-traditionally published, only get minimally read.

The shine is going to wear off the Kindles and the Nooks. Readers are already getting more discerning about what they’re willing to download. I’ve seen threads on forums where readers have asked, “How do I avoid downloading ANY self-published work ever again?” because they’ve been burned by the unedited, poorly written stuff that people are putting out there.

The fact is that this erotica “gold-rush” thing is going to end. This genre isn’t a magic bullet. And trust me when I say I’m not looking to discourage the competition. As a publisher at eXcessica, I’ve done more to help writers succeed in this genre, I think, than most. What I’m trying to discourage is the “get-rich-quick” mentality that breeds poorly written and edited stories and books–and the heartache and disillusionment that comes with it, when authors realize they’re not making the money they wanted to.

The reality is that writing isn’t easy, whether you’re writing erotica or thrillers or children’s books. Writers work hard (and erotica writers may even work harder… every pun intended!) and, as in any profession, the best ones make it look easy. I always know someone is following their calling when, watching them do what they love to do and are clearly very good at, I find myself wanting to do it too. So it’s always a compliment to me when someone says, “Wow, you make that look easy, I want to do what you do!” But I also feel a little like Simon Cowell on American Idol – I want to keep it real. I want to encourage those who are good at it, while redirecting others toward a path that may be more suited to their talents. So the whole, “How can I get rich doing what you do?” question also rankles me because it doesn’t put the focus on the writing, where it should be, but rather on the money.

When it comes down to it, erotica is like any other genre. Writing about sex might seem titillating, but in the end, those books and stories that stand the test of time will be those written by authors who loved what they were writing about, and who conveyed that to their readers.The writing that will abide will have been written by authors who didn’t worry about bottom-lines and time-investment ratios, but rather let the story lead and the characters tell their tale.

As for whether my writing will be among those?

Only time will tell!

Selena Kitt

Erotic Fiction You Won’t Forget

9 comments to Erotica Gravy Train

  • The Rodent  says:

    Mmmm, yeah, the advice from here is: don’t bother. As far as we can tell, there isn’t any money in “erotica” unless it involves pictures of naked people.

  • Tess Harding  says:

    Astute comment, Selena. Writing erotica, like writing anything, is something everyone thinks they can do – and they view erotica as “easy”. After all, everyone knows how to do the sex thing (even if it is only with themselves).

    Indie authors have opened a floodgate that others have rushed through, and as you say this leads to a reduction in overall quality. It’s probably the same with any new sphere of work, but what can be hoped is that eventually readers become discerning and discover those writers whose work is of a better standard.

    I’m not sure I agree with your premise that erotic will fade away – more likely it will grow at a slower pace, and eventually the dross will get less and less. If someone writes crap then it won’t sell and they won’t bother continuing.

    Interestingly, Amazon seems to be getting a little tighter on these things. I had an email saying I should update one of my titles because it contains a couple of typos! Wow – someone at Amazon must have actually read it.

    Oh yeah, and a response to “Rodent” – I’m not making the big bucks Selena is, but I’m paying my grocery bill month in month out for a little investment in time doing something I really enjoy.

  • Selena Kitt  says:

    I didn’t mean to imply that erotica, as a genre, will disappear. The genre itself will endure. But the current “craze” or “fad” (i.e. the erotica gravy train) won’t last forever. That, I think, will lose steam over time. There’s always been a market for it, and always will. But the Kindle and Nook have given readers a new place to read, a fun new toy to play with, and what better to explore than erotica, especially when no one can see what you’re reading? Once Kindles become as commonplace as paperbacks, though… the genre will probably go from tsunami back to the good-for-surfing sort of waves we usually have. ;)


  • Kayla  says:

    I don’t think it’s any different from anything else really. The writers set the market price as much as the customers. Customers are smart, they will find what they generally believe is good writing – or at least gives them whatever it is they want. It’s just like Neil Gaiman says really: make good art.

  • [...] approach with erotica was initially wrong (see Selena Kitt), in that I didn’t do any research and wasn’t approaching it like I would “real” writing, [...]

  • Baby Steps « antoinettemsmut  says:

    [...] approach with erotica was initially wrong (see Selena Kitt), in that I didn’t do any research and wasn’t approaching it like I would “real” writing, [...]

  • Bill  says:

    I’ve read and enjoyed some of your stories.

    Straight talk, here, but it probably won’t dissuade anyone.

  • The Long-Term Erotica Game :  says:

    [...] before the Fifty Shades phenomenon, writers were discovering that erotica was a gravy train when it came to writing. The fact that the erotica market supports selling shorter works for more [...]

  • The Long-Term Erotica Game «  says:

    [...] before the Fifty Shades phenomenon, writers were discovering that erotica was a gravy train when it came to writing. The fact that the erotica market supports selling shorter works for more [...]

Leave a reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>