Slippery Slope: Erotica Censorship

Well, the morality police are at it again. And this time, it’s scarier.

First, Amazon started banning books from their site. They backed down on their anti-censorship stance and removed the Ped0phile Guide. Then they went after books that contained incest, bestiality and rape.

After the dust settled, it was clear that, while biological incest was a no-no, Amazon would, however, allow sex between of-age adults who were related to one another in a non-biological manner–step-relations or adopted relations. Suddenly the top 100 in the Erotica category on Amazon exploded with “pseudo-incest” titles. And the covers were far more revealing than anything the category had previously carried. Titles like “Daddy Licks My Pussy” became commonplace. The line between “erotica” and “porn” had blurred even further.

Most (if not all) of these titles were written and published by “Indie” authors, who were distributing them not only through Amazon, but through other self-publishing platforms as well–Barnes and Noble, Apple, Bookstrand, All Romance Ebooks. The latter had even taken a stance against the “porn-like” covers and refused to allow them on their new releases front page, especially if they contained content relating to “pseudo-incest” and what they called “barely-legal” sex.

(I assume this is sex between an older person and someone in the age-range of 18-19. Of course, it’s interesting to note that they didn’t seem to object to the plethora of “Twink” m/m titles on their site–18-19 year old males having sex with older men. No, their objection seemed entirely against 18-19 females having sex with older men).

Soon after All Romance Ebooks had imposed these restrictions, and Bookstrand had taken Indie erotica authors off their front page as well, Bookstrand sent out an email to all of its publishers. This is from that email:

We were informed by PayPal, without notice, and by our credit card processing company, that we are required to remove all titles at BookStrand.com with content containing incest, pseudo incest, rape, and bestiality, effective immediately.

We request that you immediately log into your account and unpublish all titles that contain the restricted content.  If you have uploaded titles containing restricted content and do not unpublish these titles as we are requesting, we will deactivate your entire publisher account, which will remove all your titles from sale.

We urge you to log into your account and remove these titles as soon as possible to prevent your account from being deactivated today.

If your account is deactivated, it may or may not be reinstated in the future. After deactivation, requests for reinstatement will require us to go through your catalog, which may take several weeks or longer for us to process.

Note that they list not only “incest” but “pseudo-incest” as well. Now, while “incest” is illegal in most states, “pseudo-incest” is not. (Woody Allen, anyone?) Having sex with a step-relation or an adopted relative is just… sex. It might seem creepy or weird, but it isn’t illegal.

Now they’re not just targeting illegal acts (this is in fiction mind you) now they’re targeting acts that may simply just be “morally objectionable.” Where else do they do this? Are they targeting authors who write about serial killers?

Of course, erotica writers everywhere were up in arms. How could they do this? Why? A petition even cropped up, and it has some excellent points, if you’d like to go sign it:

Earlier this week, PayPal told Bookstrand, a major distributor of erotic romance and other erotic content on the Internet, that if certain titles containing “objectionable” material were not pulled from Bookstrand’s shelves, Bookstrand’s PayPal account would be shut down and the funds within confiscated.

PayPal has a long track record of suspending, freezing, and terminating customer accounts on the thinnest of justifications, but this is going too far. By telling Bookstrand what books they can and cannot sell using PayPal services, they are also telling readers they don’t have the right to read what they wish and telling authors that PayPal has the right to take away their freedom of speech and the press.

If you use the Internet to find new reading material, if you use PayPal, and/or if you support the rights of authors and readers to have the widest possible selection of topics to read and write about, please sign this petition and let PayPal know that censorship, no matter what form it takes or how it is implemented, is not acceptable. Readers, publishers, storefronts and authors have the right to choose what books are sold and bought.

Don’t leave it up to PayPal to choose how you spend your money or where.

The fact is, and we all know it–sex and porn make the Internet go-round. It’s a huge industry, even if there is a vocal minority who doesn’t like it. People like their porn, and they want access to it. So why would Paypal refuse to sell something that wasn’t even illegal in any state in the U.S.?

I got my chance to ask that question, because a few days after the BookStrand debacle, Excessica received a phone call from Paypal. THE phone call. And then came the follow-up letter:

After a recent review of your account activity, it has been determined that you are in violation of PayPal’s Acceptable Use Policy… In order to comply with our Acceptable Use Policy and avoid the limitation of your account, you will need to:

- Remove those items from http://www.excessica.com that violate PayPal’s Acceptable Use Policy. Example/s:  all ebooks containing themes of rape and incest.

Under the Acceptable Use Policy, PayPal may not be used to send or receive payments for certain sexually oriented materials or services or for items that could be considered obscene.

When I asked if “pseudo-incest” was included (since that was mostly all we had on the site) the representative confirmed that yes, that would have to be removed. “What about BDSM?” I asked–a category full of dubious consent. “That would have to be removed as well.”

That’s right–they weren’t just targeting illegal acts between non-consenting adults. Now they were targeting legal sex between consenting adults.

When I asked her why they were doing this, I received no answer except, “We’ve always had this policy.” Perhaps, but it seems that they weren’t previously enforcing it very seriously. Why now?

The only answer I received from Paypal was silence.

So I started to search for alternatives to Paypal. Not an easy task, I might add. Like Amazon, they are a veritable monopoly in their field. At least they graciously (ha) gave us thirty days to comply, after which the account would be frozen or cancelled. So I had some time. What I discovered was that most merchant-services (i.e. companies that allow you to use Visa and MasterCard on their site) which allow adult products charge a $5000 up-front fee to use their service. Then, they take exorbitant percentages from each transaction. Some 5%, some 14%, some as high as 25%.

Now it was starting to make more sense. The credit card companies charge higher fees for these “high-risk” accounts because there is a higher rate of what they call “chargebacks.” You know that protection on your credit card, where if you dispute the charge, you don’t have to pay for it? Well they’ve determined that happens more with porn and gambling and other “high-risk” sites than others, so they’re justified in charging more money to process payment for those sites.

Paypal doesn’t want to have to pay Visa and MC for carrying “high risk” accounts on their books. You have to remember that Paypal is a middleman. Sites that carry high-risk material have to pay the high-risk costs of doing business. If you’re going through Paypal, you don’t have to pay that. Until Paypal catches you. And then they insist you take down your high-risk content or lose your account.

What Bookstrand did was use this as an excuse to get rid of a problem. They were having difficulties integrating the harder-core Indie books into their site (although to be fair, the books in question, in terms of content, weren’t actually any more hardcore than many of the books in their Siren collection–they just had more revealing covers and more conspicuous titles) and so they used this crackdown by Paypal to eliminate hundreds of Indie books.

Who would be next? All Romance Ebooks? Smashwords? Amazon itself? Erotic writers everywhere said that Amazon was immune from Paypal’s clampdown, but were they? No, they didn’t accept Paypal on their site. But they did accept Visa and Mastercard. Where, exactly, did the buck stop?

I’m not sure, but I did find out an interesting piece of information that made me pause and consider where all of this may be leading.

Someone suggested the new “Amazon Payments” to me as an alternative to Paypal. I thought it made sense – if Amazon sells our books, why would they refuse to pay for them through their payment service?

Well guess what? I opened the account, and they closed it a day later, stating:

Thank you for registering with Amazon Payments. We appreciate your interest in our product.

Unfortunately, at this time, we are not able to approve your request for an Amazon Payments Business Account based on our review of your intended use of our payments service.

As stated in our Acceptable Use Policy the following product or services are prohibited from using Amazon Payments:

Adult Oriented Products and Services – includes pornography (including child pornography), sexually explicit materials (in all media types such as Internet, phone, and printed materials), dating services, escort services, or prostitution services.

While we appreciate your interest, the blocking of your account is a permanent action. Please feel free to write to us for any questions that you may have.

Which means, Amazon may not be “immune” to the Paypal rules after all. Because they still have to process credit cards through the same credit card companies that Paypal does.

I don’t know what this means for the future of erotic self-publishing, but like the banning of certain titles begun by Amazon, it is a very slippery slope indeed. Today it’s “pseudo-incest” and “rape” (including BDSM titles) which is nothing more than legal sex between consenting adults.

What will it be tomorrow?

EDITED TO ADD:

I’m putting this addendum here, rather than create another blog post, because so many people are linking to it. Bookstrand took the final step and completely eliminated “most of the Indie titles” from their site. They sent an email stating they wanted to “go back to their roots.” Whatever that means. Of course, this decision came without warning, and while Indie authors were still trying to comply with their (ever-changing!) new Terms of Service.

Then Bookstrand said to DearAuthor that Siren “NEVER has and NEVER will publish books with the disgusting themes of incest, pseudo incest, rape for sexual titillation, or bestiality with naturally occurring animals.”

No, they don’t publish them. (Except for this one. And this one. Oh and this one). But they sure as heck didn’t have a problem distributing them and making 50% commission on selling them before Paypal said, “Hey, you can’t do that!” did they? Nope. No problem cashing that check. And they’ve been selling our stuff (incest and pseudo) since 2008. Hypocrite much?

Well I guess we couldn’t expect them not to cave to Paypal. I just wished they’d done it with more regret and class.

And I wondered who might be next, didn’t I? Well… here we go…

All Romance Ebooks has been contacted by Paypal and given the same ultimatum as Book Strand. They have now changed their policies and are implementing a new structure, splitting erotic romance from erotica. Of course, the concern is that perhaps they, like Bookstrand, will simply use that structure to lop off erotica as a category and go without it. Only time will tell.

In the interest of transparency, here is the letter from All Romance Ebooks:

This communication is being sent out to all publishers since it involves a process change:

From the beginning, we conceived of All Romance as a niche bookstore that would sell a wide variety of romance novels. Our primary demographic is adult women who enjoy reading romance subgenres featuring stories between two consenting adults. We opened with an “Erotica” category and, until fairly recently, that category was dominated primarily by Erotic Romance, which was our intent. “Vampires/Werewolves” was intended to carry romances featuring Vampires and Werewolves. “Gay” was intended to carry romances featuring Gay men. Over the past few months we’ve begun to receive more and more pure Erotica titles. Admittedly, there is a segment of our readership that wants to read Erotica. There is another segment that prefers to read Erotic Romance. Still others enjoy both, or neither.

In order to improve discoverability for all, we’ve decided to create separate Erotic Romance and Erotica categories. The “old” Erotica category will soon be retired. All titles in that category will need to be re-shelved prior to its retirement to avoid inactivation. We have also made some amendments to our restrictive section to provide some further guidance as to the types of books we feel will resonate best with our Romance community. Please review section 7 of the publisher contract here. If the amended terms are ones you can’t abide by, please let Barbara know and she will accept your notice of termination. If they are, accessing your publisher panel after today will be sufficient to constitute acceptance. We request that you take immediate initiative to remove any titles that may be in breach.

In order to help publishers shelve titles appropriately and aid readers in finding the types of books they most want to enjoy, we’ve worked in conjunction with a team of Erotica and Erotic Romance authors and publishers to craft some guidelines. We appreciate that this division is rather nuanced and that our views may not equate with yours. None-the-less, these guidelines will serve to direct customers, so we ask that you refer to them when deciding upon category placement.

In the next one to two weeks, you will receive notice that re-shelving has commenced. You will have seven calendar days in which to complete the re-shelving process. During the seven-day period, only titles in the New Erotica and New Erotic Romance categories will be visible to the public. If you publish all Erotica or all Erotica Romance, you’ll be able to complete the process with one simple step upon login. If you would like us to complete that step for you, please send an email to me, Subject: Shelving. Indicate in the body of the email if you publisher only Erotica or Erotica Romance. I will confirm with you via email when your migration is complete.

If you publish a mixture of Erotica and Erotic Romance, when re-shelving begins upon login you will be directed to a pop-up page that lists only your current Erotica content along with summaries. You will need to check a box for each title, indicating whether it falls into the Erotica or Erotic Romance category.

I’m including our guidelines below so that you can begin planning for this process:

Erotic romance is a Romance containing frequent, sexually explicit love scenes. The main plot centers around two or more people falling in love and struggling to make the relationship work. The love scenes are a natural part of the romance and described using graphic and frank language. Typically these stories have an HEA (happily ever a fter) or HFN (happy for now) ending.

Erotica is a sexually explicit story, which explores and focuses on a character’s sexual journey rather than an emphasis on a developing romantic relationship. While such an erotic story may have elements of romance, it is the sex that primarily drives the story.

I find this rather questionable:

“…accessing your publisher panel after today will be sufficient to constitute acceptance.”

So if we want to log in and see our sales or look at our titles, we have to accept these new terms of service? This smacks of what Bookstrand did. They gave no notice to publishers of the terms of service changes (and seemed to change them every five minutes!) and certainly gave no indication that they would be removing the entire “Indie” section of books until it happened. All Romance Ebooks has followed their example, deactivating books and then saying, “Oh by the way, when you log into your account to find out what’s going on, you agree to our new Terms of Service.” Really!? No box to check, nothing. The contract was amended without anyone’s knowledge or consent and then come to find out that logging in to figure out what’s going when publishers find their books gone means they somehow agree with the stuff they weren’t told about? That’s so not cool.

And what are All Romance Ebooks’ new restrictions? Funny, they look similar to the issues Paypal was having with the Bookstrand books. Incest, pseudo-incest, bestiality and rape. All Romance, however, has taken this one step further, and has banned “barely legal” (their term) books. This is, apparently, sex between 18-19 year old women and older men, at least if the books they’ve banned so far are any indication. Of course, they have lots and lots of “twink” books (18-19 year old males having sex with older men). So far, no banning of those. Double standard much!?

These will sound familiar:

7. Restrictions

All Romance reserves the right not to accept any particular Work submitted by Publisher at All Romance’s sole discretion, and may remove any particular Work from sale at any time and for any or no reason. Pornographic and obscene Works are restricted and not allowable for upload on the All Romance site, including without limitation, Works depicting sexual acts involving persons under eighteen years of age (exceptions may be made for certain works of literary fiction involving time periods wherein the age of consent was less than 18 and the purpose of the depiction is not for sexual titillation), Works involving any exploitation of minors, sexual or otherwise, Erotic Works which contain incest or pseudo-incest themes, Works that are written for or being marketed to the barely legal market, rape for the purposes of titillation, scenes of non-consensual bondage or non-consensual sado-masochistic practices, bestiality with naturally occurring animals, sex with non-animated corpses, snuff or scat play.

Well.

Two distributors down.

Next?

90 comments to Slippery Slope: Erotica Censorship

  • [...] situations like bestiality, rape, incest, or underage characters. More recently, PayPal told author Selena Kitt that BDSM ebooks “would have to be removed as well” from her online bookstore, eXcessica. Additionally, [...]

  • [...] situations like bestiality, rape, incest, or underage characters. More recently, PayPal told author Selena Kitt that BDSM ebooks “would have to be removed as well” from her online bookstore, eXcessica. Additionally, [...]

  • [...] situations like bestiality, rape, incest, or underage characters. More recently, PayPal told author Selena Kitt that BDSM ebooks “would have to be removed as well” from her online bookstore, eXcessica. Additionally, [...]

  • [...] situations like bestiality, rape, incest, or underage characters. More recently, PayPal told author Selena Kitt that BDSM ebooks “would have to be removed as well” from her online bookstore, eXcessica. Additionally, [...]

  • [...] 19th: Slippery Slope: Erotica Censorship (Selina Kitt) *  ***, Slippery Slope: Erotica Censorship (cross-posted at her personal blog) * Censorship… Who Has the Right? (One-Handed Writers) [...]

  • Paypal Puts Publishers’ Panties In A Wad | WebProNews  says:

    [...] to the news and the issue has been heated. An article written by Selena Kitt, entitled, “Slippery Slope: Erotica Censorship” posted on her blog had a big response. [...]

  • [...] I’m not one-hundred percent certain where the purge began. There is a very extensive blog post by an erotic writer who goes by the name Selena Kitt that gives her first hand experience. The first we at Crimson Melodies received notice this was [...]

  • Stephanie Draven  says:

    I don’t like some of the things you write about. I don’t have to. You have my support, and I hope that this primer will help you in the debates that will come.

  • PayPal censors Smashwords « Digital Authors  says:

    [...] types of "obscene" content. For good background on the issue, see this Selena Kitt post here - http://selenakitt.com/blog/index.php/2012/02/19/slippery-slope-erotica-censorship/ or here [...]

  • PayPal censors Smashwords « Digital Authors  says:

    [...] types of "obscene" content. For good background on the issue, see this Selena Kitt post here - http://selenakitt.com/blog/index.php/2012/02/19/slippery-slope-erotica-censorship/ or here [...]

  • Gustavo Carneiro  says:

    Have you heard of Bitcoin? See http://bitcoin.org/

  • squirrel  says:

    In many ways, I’m sympathetic, but at the same time, we have to remember we’re not being completely censored. We can still post our stories all we like anywhere we want – we’ve just hit a roadblock to making money. I’m a fanfic writer who dabbles in stuff that definitely would not be allowed under these policies. We’re still free to write and post what we want!

    When Livejournal started censoring the fanfic writers for similar reasons (incest, bestiality, etc), we found other places to set up camp (Dreamjournal and Archive of Our Own are two of the more popular places). I’m confident that the adult fiction community will find a different way to monetize their works. There’s bound to be would-be PayPal alternatives out there chomping at the bit to take your money! Lifehacker has an interesting article on PayPal alternatives for those interested in googling it.

  • [...] Selena Kitt offered a conspiracy theory that credit card companies are trying to equate erotica ebooks with online porn (which is a “high risk” purchase because of high returns against charges) and are raising processing fees for erotica ebooks to those of porn sites, a fee hike PayPal doesn’t want to deal with.   No Boundaries Press says the credit card companies they talked to shut down that speculation with the bottom line, “as long as you spend they don’t care [on what].”  While the libertarian in me would love to point to this and say “unintended but entirely predictable consequence of Dodd-Frank,” I really don’t think that’s the case.  I think PayPal realized they had a shitstorm of epic proportions brewing and wanted to try to spread the blame across the entire financial sector.  [...]

  • [...] Selena Kitt on the Slippery Slope [...]

  • The Corporate Censorship of Erotica | Pegasus Pulp  says:

    [...] author Selena Kitt has two great posts about this sudden crackdown on erotica and why it matters to all of us, even those who [...]

  • Art Mealer  says:

    I am very much in favor of an organization’s right to NOT be forced to carry materials they deem to be “bestiality, rape-for-titillation, incest and underage erotica.” How hypocritical for liberals promote and push “political correctness” to enforce their restrictions in the public domain of free speech, yet complain about unfair censorship when others exercise their judgement on what types of materials to not promote through their organizations.

  • Theresa M  says:

    Orwell anyone?? I really can’t believe that this is happening…is this 2012 or 1984? Never in my wildest dreams did I imagine that we would be taking the back steps in our personal freedoms that are happening here and now. I shudder to think what could possibly be next.

  • j.c. wilde  says:

    Selena,

    Thought you might find this funny!!! :)

    Two People Having Sex : An Erotic Parody That Meets PalPay Standards of Censorship

    https://www.smashwords.com/books/view/139100

    Hahaha!
    xoxo

  • [...] Heavier reading: Go here. [...]

  • [...] on the other hand, posted a statement (as reported by author Selena Kitt) saying that We were informed by PayPal, without notice, and by our credit card processing company, [...]

  • [...] Selena Kitt meldt dat niet alleen Smashwords, maar nog veel meer sites getroffen zijn door de nieuwe [...]

  • [...] take the extraordinary step of censoring legal books. The only answer I’ve seen so far is in a post by writer Selena Kitt. I quote, “What I discovered was that most merchant-services (i.e. companies that allow you [...]

  • The Erotic Harvest  says:

    [...] was quiet here because I was using my voice elsewhere. Supporting authors like Remittance Girl and Selena Kitt, who were among the first authors to make people aware of what was going on. I have been signing [...]

  • [...] Slippery Slope: Erotica Censorship (http://selenakitt.com/) [...]

  • [...] of Excessica Publishing relays a phone call and follow-up letter received from Paypal. See the post here. Note that your representative applied the definitions for incest to Pseudo-Incest and rape to [...]

  • [...] of Excessica Publishing relays a phone call and follow-up letter received from Paypal. See the post here. Note that your representative applied the definitions for incest to Pseudo-Incest and rape to [...]

  • [...] author Selena Kitt blogged about PayPal’s actions early on (before it started in on Smashwords, PayPal hit several [...]

  • Paypal Bans Sales of the Bible | Irreducible Complexity  says:

    [...] February Paypal went on the offensive to target small-press and independent publishers of books containing sexual content including: [...]

  • Superjail! and Censorship « Antoinette M–  says:

    [...] smut authors are subject to all manner of censorship, subtle and overt. See Selena Kitt for an expanded discussion. Please note: she has other posts on the subject as well, which are all worth reading, or at least [...]

  • Amazon’s Censoring Taboo Erotica |  says:

    [...] wanted to blog about this because it was a year ago that there was a call to arms about PayPal, about how it was treating companies that sold erotica, and how it made so many people rise up. [...]

  • [...] wanted to blog about this because it was a year ago that there was a call to arms about PayPal, about how it was treating companies that sold erotica, and how it made so many people rise up. [...]

  • [...] situations like bestiality, rape, incest, or underage characters. More recently, PayPal told author Selena Kitt that BDSM ebooks “would have to be removed as well” from her online bookstore, eXcessica. Additionally, [...]

  • Amazon’s Censoring Taboo Erotica | Keep It Up  says:

    [...] wanted to blog about this because it was a year ago that there was a call to arms about PayPal, about how it was treating companies that sold erotica, and how it made so many people rise up. [...]

  • [...] those of you unfamiliar with the Paypal Censorship issue of last winter, PayPal told Smashwords, All Romance eBooks, and other sites that PayPal would [...]

  • [...] those of you unfamiliar with the Paypal Censorship issue of last winter, PayPal told Smashwords, All Romance eBooks, and other sites that PayPal would [...]

  • […] a slippery slope, and Selena Kitt has already written about it here. And here. And there’s an active thread on kindle boards […]

  • Monster Erotica Makes the News… Again | Monster Erotic  says:

    […] Slippery Slope […]

  • […] in any way with adult services or performers does not seem to be enforced across the board. Multiple erotica sites dealt with PayPal, telling them that “morally objectionable” content wasn’t […]

  • […] in any way with adult services or performers does not seem to be enforced across the board. Multiple erotica sites dealt with PayPal, telling them that “morally objectionable” content wasn’t […]

Leave a reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>